Short answer. We have collected 68 reasons why emails land in spam and grouped them into four areas: copy and design (30%), sending schedule and list quality (30%), technical setup (30%) and the unpredictable (10%). Go through the checklist below: if even one item applies to you, that is most likely where the problem is.
After 10+ years and more than 1,200 projects, the EmailConsulting team has noticed that nobody goes to spam “out of nowhere”. It is almost always a handful of small issues that have built up over time. This checklist will help you find them in 15 minutes.
The 30/30/30/10 rule
Mailbox providers (Outlook, Gmail, Yahoo, iCloud and the ISP mailboxes such as BT and Sky) don’t judge a single email. They judge the whole chain: your domain, your email service provider (ESP), the copy and how recipients behave. That is why the causes of spam split almost evenly:
- 30%: copy and design. What you write and how the email is built.
- 30%: sending schedule and list. Who you send to, how much and how often.
- 30%: technical setup. DNS records, domain, sender address.
- 10%: the unpredictable. Things that can’t always be foreseen.
Fixing one area is not enough. Perfect DNS records won’t save an email with ALL CAPS in the subject line, and clean copy won’t save a send to a bought list.
In the UK there is one more thing to keep in mind: a large share of your subscribers read email in Outlook, Hotmail and Microsoft 365, so Microsoft’s filters matter as much as Gmail’s. Let’s go through each area and see what could be sending your emails to spam.
Checklist: 68 reasons your emails go to spam
1. Copy and design (30%)
Copy and subject line
- Spam trigger words and pushy sales phrases: “Free”, “Guaranteed”, “Act now”, “Winner”, “100%”, “Click here”.
- False urgency: “Urgent!”, “Last chance”, “Verify your account”.
- ALL CAPS and several exclamation marks in a row, especially in words like “SALE!!!”.
- Currency symbols used for effect: “£££”, “Save £££”.
- A subject line that doesn’t match the content: people open, feel misled and click “Report spam”.
- Too many emoji in the subject line and body.
- AI-written “salesy” copy that hasn’t been checked against spam filters.
- Machine-translated copy that reads unnaturally to a native English speaker.
- Mixed alphabets: Cyrillic characters that look like Latin letters in the text or sender name, a classic phishing signal.
Design
- Bold, italics and coloured text used for emphasis.
- Several fonts and more than 2–3 text sizes in one email.
- Harsh colour contrast: bright backgrounds, neon buttons, coloured text on a coloured background.
- The email is one large image, or has very little text compared with images.
- Images without alt text.
- Leftover code in the template: stray dots, empty blocks, hidden text.
- A “burnt-out” template that has been used for so long that filters now associate it with spam.
Links and code
- Links point to different websites rather than one domain that matches your sending domain.
- URL shorteners.
- Too many links in one email.
- Links to websites with a poor reputation.
- Heavy HTML code: Gmail clips emails larger than about 100 KB.
- Attachments in bulk emails, which Microsoft 365 business filters treat with particular suspicion.
- No clearly visible unsubscribe link in the body of the email.
2. Sending schedule and list (30%)
Volume and consistency
- A new domain sending to more than 2,000 contacts straight away.
- Sudden volume spikes: a quiet week followed by tens of thousands of emails in a day.
- Irregular sending: daily one week, then nothing for two months.
- Switching to a new ESP and sending full volumes immediately.
- Sending at times that suit you rather than your audience: a campaign sent at 9:00 Kyiv time arrives at 7:00 in London (GMT/BST).
List quality and consent
- Sending to a bought, rented or scraped list.
- No valid consent under PECR, or soft opt-in applied to people who have never bought from you.
- No company name and postal address in the footer: recipients don’t know who is writing to them.
- Subscribers don’t recognise your brand or don’t remember signing up.
- Lots of invalid addresses: a bounce rate above 2–5%.
- An old list that hasn’t been cleaned for years and may contain spam traps.
- Mailing everyone, including people who haven’t opened an email in six months or more.
Recipient engagement
- Spam complaints above 0.1% (Gmail and Yahoo require you never to reach 0.3%).
- Unsubscribe rate above 1%: you send too often or the content isn’t relevant.
- Click rate below 1%.
- Judging list health by open rate alone: Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens, so a falling click rate is the earlier warning sign.
- Resending to non-openers on a domain whose reputation is already weak.
3. Technical setup (30%)
Domain authentication
- SPF is missing, or there are two or more SPF records (there should be one, with no more than 10 DNS lookups).
- DKIM is missing or not active.
- No DMARC record.
- The domain in the From field doesn’t align with the DKIM signing domain.
- Old DNS records from a previous ESP that conflict with the new ones.
- No CNAME record for link tracking.
Mailbox provider requirements in 2026
- No one-click unsubscribe (List-Unsubscribe header, RFC 8058), which Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft require from bulk senders.
- Not meeting Microsoft’s sender requirements for Outlook.com and Hotmail, in force since May 2025: non-compliant bulk mail is rejected with error 550 5.7.515.
- Sending without TLS encryption or from an IP without a valid PTR record. This is usually your ESP’s area, so check with their support team.
Outlook and Microsoft 365
- Outlook users rarely open, reply to or move your emails, so Microsoft files you under “Other” instead of “Focused”, and later in Junk.
- You never ask subscribers to add you to their contacts or Safe Senders list.
- B2B recipients on Microsoft 365 are protected by Exchange Online Protection and Defender, which are stricter about links and attachments than consumer mailboxes.
- Safe Links in Microsoft 365 scans every link and registers “clicks” nobody made, so you misread engagement and keep mailing the wrong people.
Domain and sender address
- A brand-new domain, a few days old, already sending bulk email.
- Marketing, triggered and transactional emails all sent from one domain.
- A low-trust top-level domain such as .bet, .casino, .info or .top; .co.uk and .com are safer choices.
- Spam words or extra characters (hyphens, digits) in the domain name.
- A generic sender address: info@, noreply@, office@.
- Replies go to a mailbox that doesn’t exist or that nobody reads.
- The sender name, links or footer point to another country or language, which doesn’t match a UK audience.
Monitoring
- Google Postmaster Tools is not set up, so you can’t see your Gmail reputation.
- Microsoft SNDS and JMRP are not set up, so you can’t see your reputation and complaints in Outlook.
- No seed list of test mailboxes at Outlook, Gmail, Yahoo, iCloud, BT and Sky, or tests sent with the “Send test” button instead of as a real campaign.
4. The unpredictable (10%)
- Your ESP’s shared IP was blocklisted because of other senders.
- Your domain or IP is on a blocklist.
- A mailbox provider changed its filtering algorithms.
- An outage or configuration change on your ESP’s side.
- A combination of factors that only shows up in a detailed audit.
Summary
Go through every item on the checklist honestly. If you recognise a cause, dig into it and fix it: correct your DNS, clean your list, rewrite the copy, even out your sending schedule. Each area is covered in detail in the next articles in this series.
If you can’t find the cause or fix it yourself, talk to an agency. We will run an anti-spam audit: we check your technical setup, domain and IP reputation in Gmail and Outlook, your copy and your sending schedule, and give you a step-by-step plan to get back into the inbox.